Internatıonal Organızatıon And Global Governance Deneme Sınavı Sorusu #841819

Which of the following is a criticism legalist approach has received from a liberal perspective?


There may be a risk that everything may be managed by the threat of punishment to maintain order.

There may be a certain disbelief in the potentiality of human beings in this legalistic proposal- a certain fear from the future.

The order aimed to achieve by legalists may fail to appeal people who want to live in a world where they pursue their own truths. 

They fail to consider the consequences of legalism by setting certain rules for action by an authority.

They take domestic analogy as the starting point, but they are mistaken the role of the government in domestic politics.


Yanıt Açıklaması:

The domestic analogy of legalists may be flawed, because, especially from a liberal perspective, order refers to the political management of group relations rather than either law making or enforcing the law on individuals or nations. Legalists’ starting point has been the domestic analogy, but they too have somewhat mistaken the role of the government in domestic politics.

From a pragmatic perspective, one should ask the question what this world order, if realized at all, would mean for the individual’s life and for the nations’ future. Pragmatism looks at the consequences (to the “fruits”) of a certain rule for action. Imagine a world where individuals and other entities in the world would act only according to the rules established by an authority. This would not be an order at all for peoples who would like to live in a world where they feel free so as to pursue their own truths, beliefs, and dreams. There may be a certain disbelief in the potentiality of human beings in this legalistic proposal- a certain fear from the future, so that everything should be managed by the threat of punishment. This is a liberal way of approaching to neither human relations nor to political government.

Yorumlar
  • 0 Yorum